The Chinese University of Hong Kong Business School Announces Five Business Sustainability Indices to Promote Responsible Business Practices in Hong Kong and Greater China

HONG KONG SAR – Media OutReach – 24 June 2021 – The Chinese University of Hong Kong (CUHK) Business School’s Centre for Business Sustainability (CBS) announces today results of the 6^th Hong Kong Business Sustainability Index (HKBSI), the 2^nd Greater Bay Area Business Sustainability Index (GBABSI) and the 6^th Hong Kong SME Business Sustainability Index (HKSMEBSI), as well as launches the 1^st Greater China Business Sustainability Index (GCBSI) and the 1^st Greater China Hotel Business Sustainability Index (Hotel BSI).

 

The unique “Values – Process – Impact” (VPI) model, which was developed and launched in 2015 by CBS, is used in the assessment of all the five Business Sustainability Indices (BSI). Each index company was assessed in three major areas, namely Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) Values, CSR Process (comprising CSR Management and Practice) and CSR Impact against seven stakeholder groups (Community, Consumer, Employee, Environment, Government, Investor and Supplier), as well as the company’s contributions to economic, social and environmental sustainability. As the Technical Partner of the projects, SGS Hong Kong Limited conducted sample check and verification of the information provided by individual companies. The Sinyi School of NCCU College of Commerce in Taiwan also helped compile the data of Taiwan companies in the GCBSI.

 

The 6^th HKBSI

HKBSI is aimed at charting the ongoing development and performance of Hang Seng Index constituent companies on business sustainability. Compared to the results of the 5^th HKBSI released last August, the overall average score of the 50 Hang Seng Index (HSI) constituent companies as at 31 July 2020 was 58.66 (out of 100 points), up by 1.95 percent.

 

Within the VPI model, the average score of “Values” and “Process-Practice” remained stable compared with that of the 5^th HKBSI, while “Process-Management” improved slightly with a 7.33 percent rise but “Impact” dropped by 2.43 percent. In terms of stakeholder analysis, companies showed improvement in Practices such as Employee (5.14 percent rise), Government (up by 2.75 percent), Investor (3.44 percent increase) and Supplier (4.03 percent rise).

 

Currently, more than half (52 percent) of HSI constituent companies are non-Hong Kong based companies, comprising of H-shares, red chips and other mainland Chinese firms listed in Hong Kong. The overall average score of these non-Hong Kong based companies in the 6^th HKBSI recorded a 2.89 percent rise to 50.96 (out of 100 points) when compared to a rise of just 1.18 percent to 67 points for Hong Kong based companies, showing that non-Hong Kong based companies exhibited a bigger performance improvement in business sustainability, especially in CSR management, which was up by 9.39 percent.

 

Prof. Carlos Lo, Director of CBS, explained, “A salient trend can be observed in the stakeholder analysis is a significant increase of the CSR practices over three out of the four value chain stakeholder groups, namely, Employee (up 5.14 percent), Supplier (up 4.03 percent) and Investor (up 3.14 percent) in comparing with the results in the last round. Still Customer records a slightly increase of 0.45 percent. This indicates the positive development of continuous integration of CSR into corporate core business.”

 

The 2^nd GBABSI

CBS extended its sustainability index project to cover Hong Kong listed companies with operations in Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area that are eligible for southbound trading under the Stock Connect scheme last year. A total of 66 constituent companies of the Hang Seng Stock Connect Hong Kong Greater Bay Area Index as at 31 July 2020 were invited to complete an online assessment questionnaire for the 2^nd GBABSI with the same scope as HKBSI.

 

Benchmarking against the 6^th HKBSI results (58.66 points), the overall average score (52.86 points) of the GBABSI companies was still lower, but the performance gap was narrowing with a significant improvement in all the four aspects (Values, Process-Management, Process-Practice and Impact) from 10.70 percent, 12.80 percent, 15.80 percent to 26.27 percent respectively.

 

GCBSI – the First-of-its-Kind Sustainability Performance Measurement for Listed Companies in Greater China

To encourage and motivate companies in the Greater China region to integrate CSR initiatives into everyday business, CBS rolls out the GCBSI to cover 200 listed companies from HSI, FTSE TWSE Taiwan 50 Index, Shenzhen 100 Index and Shanghai Stock Exchange SSE 50 A Share Index.

 

In the inaugural GCBSI, the overall average score is 43.11 with an extremely high standard deviation. Specifically, listed companies from Taiwan outperformed those from Hong Kong and mainland China with an average score of 66.05, which is followed by listed companies in Hong Kong (58.66 points), Shanghai (36.56 points) and Shenzhen (26.73 points). Six out of the Top 10 in the 1^st GCBSI were Hong Kong companies, and half of the Top 20 companies were from Taiwan. The Hong Kong and China Gas Company Limited and BOC Hong Kong (Holdings) Limited held the top and the second spots, respectively, in the GCBSI, GBABSI and HKBSI. In terms of stakeholder analysis, Taiwan companies maintained a balanced performance in all the seven stakeholder practices, while Shanghai and Shenzhen companies put a relatively stronger emphasis on government and investor.

“These results provide strong evidence to show the comparable standard between companies listed in Hong Kong and Taiwan in performing CSR for achieving sustainability among the Top 20 performers, while those listed in Shanghai and Shenzhen are on the whole in the catching up stage. There is a lot for Mainland-listed companies to learn from their Hong Kong and Taiwan counterparts in sustainability management,” explained Prof. Lo.

 

Hotel BSI – the First Business Sustainability Index for Listed Hotel Companies in Greater China

In a collaboration with Centre for Hospitality and Real Estate Research (CHRER) at CUHK Business School’s School of Hotel and Tourism Management, results of the inaugural Hotel BSI were also announced today, showing that leading international hotel chains and companies listed in Greater China are showing increasing concern for CSR and business sustainability.

 

The 1^st Hotel BSI shows the annual business sustainability performance for the financial year ended in 2019-20, based on publicly available information of the 36 listed hotel companies in Greater China and six large international hotel chains. It aims at engaging hotel companies in continuous optimisation of CSR hotel practices, and thereby achieve sustainable development and concurrent growth to the benefit of both businesses and society.

 

Half of the hotel companies achieved over 50 points and reached the “Performer” level, which is comparable to internationally recognised standards of excellence in CSR. Currently, 61 percent of the Hotel BSI constituent companies are Hong Kong and Macau based companies or one of six international hotel chains, and 22 percent are Taiwan based and 17 percent are mainland China based. The Top 10 performers were mostly international hotel chains or Hong Kong listed companies, and only one non-Hong Kong based company entered the Top 10.

 

The 6^th HKSMEBSI

Compiled and announced biannually since 2015, HKSMEBSI aims at inspiring small and medium enterprises (SMEs) in Hong Kong to adopt CSR as a management model to enable them to achieve business sustainability. A total of 27 SMEs with proven track records in CSR performance, namely, winners of major CSR related awards, were invited to complete an assessment questionnaire pertaining to their CSR performance for the preceding two years. For the 6^th HKSMEBSI, the assessment was based on the 2020 data provided by the companies.

 

The overall average score of the index companies in the 6^th HKSMEBSI is 78.73 (out of 100 points), a slight improvement compared with that of the 5^th HKSMEBSI announced in 2019. Among the seven stakeholder practices, in comparison with the results of the 5^th HKSMEBSI, community, customer and government saw improvement. Unlike the listed companies evaluated in the 6^th HKBSI, the scores in Investor and Supplier practices decreased by 16.94 percent and 15.22 percent respectively.

Prof. Lo said, “It is very encouraging to see SMEs sustaining their high level of CSR performance, despite the difficult year of 2020, particularly in the delivery of their CSR initiatives. The stakeholder analysis has indicated that Customer remains the most important stakeholder group in the value chain than Investor and Supplier that received the greatest SMEs’ sustainability management attention. It is understandable that business survival is the top priority for SMEs of. At the same time, it is pleased to see their continuous and active pursuit of community engagement.”

 

The Inaugural Hotel BSI lays a good foundation for the compilation of a Global Hotel BSI. In 2022, CBS will continue to work with CHRER to introduce a BSI covering 80 listed hotel companies worldwide. This can not only encourage companies in the hotel industry to adopt CSR as a progressive business model to achieve business sustainability, but also serve as a robust indicator for ESG investors in selecting companies with socially responsible corporate behaviour. Furthermore, CBS will work closely with the Asia-Pacific Institute of Business, the executive education arm of CUHK Business School, on designing more training programmes and workshops on CSR applications and communication for the business community. Understand that business sustainability is an unended quest that requires companies to build management capacity on a continuous basis, CBS has set its future endeavour on cultivating sustainability talents by developing sustainability management into a knowledge-based profession. This includes the formulation of a qualification framework for the sustainability profession, the support of setting up of a sustainability professional association, and the organisation of sustainability management programme.

 

Please visit https://bit.ly/3j4CT7E to read the press release on the CUHK Business School website.

Appendix

The 6^th HKBSI

 

Overall VPI Scores

	6th HKBSI		5th HKBSI		Changes (6th vs 5th HKBSI)
	Mean Score	Performance Level	Mean Score	Performance Level
Total	58.66	Practicer	57.54	Practicer	+1.95%
Values	65.54	Performer	65.22	Performer	+0.49%
Process – Management	71.48	Performer	66.60	Performer	+7.33%
Process – Practice	66.51	Performer	65.31	Performer	+1.84%
Impact	37.68	Explorer	38.62	Explorer	-2.43%

 

Stakeholder
Analysis

Practice	6th HKBSI	5th HKBSI	Changes (6th vs 5th HKBSI)
Overall Scores	66.51	65.31	1.84%
Community	61.64	62.50	-1.38%
Customer	69.12	68.81	0.45%
Employee	70.43	66.99	5.14% ↑
Environment	67.40	67.26	0.21%
Government	53.80	52.36	2.75% ↑
Investor	74.26	71.79	3.44% ↑
Supplier	63.83	61.36	4.03% ↑

 

Overall Scores – HK vs.
Non-HK Based Companies

		Total		Values		Process – Management		Process – Practice		Impact
HK based	6th HKBSI	67.00	1.18%	72.33	0.51%	80.50	5.63%	75.98	1.86%	45.48	-3.97%
	5th HKBSI	66.22		71.96		76.21		74.59		47.36
Non-HK based	6th HKBSI	50.96	2.89%	59.27	0.46%	63.15	9.39%	57.77	1.86%	30.49	-0.16%
	5th HKBSI	49.53		59.00		57.73		56.73		30.54

 

The Top 10 HKBSI Company Ranking

1.      Hong Kong and China Gas Co., Ltd.

2.      BOC Hong Kong (Holdings) Ltd.

3.      HSBC Holdings plc

4.      Sun Hung Kai Properties Ltd.

5.      Hang Seng Bank Ltd.

6.      MTR Corporation Limited

7.      New World Development Co., Ltd.

8.      CLP Holdings Ltd.

9.      Sands China Ltd.

10.   Sino Land Co., Ltd.

The 2^nd GBABSI

Overall VPI Scores

	2nd GBABSI		1st GBABSI		Changes (2nd vs 1st GBABSI)
	Mean Score	Performance Level	Mean Score	Performance Level
Total	52.86	Practicer	45.60	Practicer	+15.92%
Values	53.47	Practicer	48.30	Practicer	+10.70%
Process – Management	61.64	Performer	54.90	Performer	+12.28%
Process – Practice	61.79	Performer	53.36	Performer	+15.80%
Impact	37.68	Explorer	29.84	Explorer	+26.27%

 

The Top 10 GBABSI Company Ranking

1.      Hong Kong and China Gas Co., Ltd.

2.      BOC Hong Kong (Holdings) Ltd.

3.      Sun Hung Kai Properties Ltd.

4.      Hang Seng Bank Ltd.

5.      MTR Corporation Limited

6.      New World Development Co., Ltd.

7.      China Resource Power Holdings Co., Ltd.

8.      Sands China Ltd.

9.      Sino Land Co., Ltd.

10.   Kerry Properties Ltd.

The 1^st GCBSI

 

Overall VPI Scores

	Total	Values	Process – Management	Process – Practice	Impact
1st GCBSI – Taiwan	66.05 (Performer)	71.42	86.42	71.02	43.91
1st GCBSI – Shanghai	36.56 (Explorer)	44.54	36.72	44.15	23.53
1st GCBSI – Shenzhen	26.73 (Explorer)	27.74	25.60	37.26	16.27
6th HKBSI	58.66 (Practicer)	66.54	71.48	66.51	37.68

 

Stakeholder Analysis

	Community	Consumer	Employee	Environment	Government	Investor	Supplier
1st GCBSI – Taiwan	70.82	74.05	77.83	67.16	54.68	79.70	64.97
1st GCBSI – Shanghai	41.13	41.82	48.22	33.79	67.08	64.48	26.49
1st GCBSI – Shenzhen	29.35	32.28	42.92	28.29	57.06	65.64	22.17
6th HKBSI	48.56	61.26	62.26	54.68	61.15	65.49	55.16

 

The Top 10 GCBSI Company Ranking

1.	Hong Kong and China Gas Co., Ltd.	Hong Kong
2.	BOC Hong Kong (Holdings) Ltd.	Hong Kong
3.	HSBC Holdings plc	Hong Kong
4.	Ctbc Financial Holding Co., Ltd.	Taiwan
5.	Sun Hung Kai Properties Ltd.	Hong Kong
6.	Hang Seng Bank Ltd.	Hong Kong
7.	Lite-On Technology Corporation	Taiwan
8.	Taiwan Mobile Co., Ltd.	Taiwan
9.	MTR Corporation Limited	Hong Kong
10.	Far Eastern New Century Corporation	Taiwan

 

The Top 20 GCBSI Companies (in alphabetical order)

·           Asustek Computer Inc.	Taiwan
·           Cathay Financial Holding Co., Ltd.	Taiwan
·           Chunghwa Telecom	Taiwan
·           CLP Holdings Ltd.	Hong Kong
·           Fubon Financial.	Taiwan
·           New World Development Co., Ltd	Hong Kong
·           Sands China Ltd.	Hong Kong
·           Sino Land Co. Ltd.	Hong Kong
·           Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company Limited	Taiwan
·           United Microelectronics Corp.	Taiwan

The 1^st Hotel BSI

Overall Performance Level

Rank	1st Hotel BSI
90-100 points Exemplar	0	—
80-89 points Pace-setter	3	8.33%
70-79 points Achiever	1	2.78%
60-69 points Performer	2	5.56%
50-59 points Practicer	12	33.33%
Below 50 points Explorer	18	50%

 

The Top 10
Hotel BSI Performers (in alphabetical order)

• Accor SA
• FDC
  International Hotels Corporation
• Hilton Worldwide
  Holdings Inc.
• Hong Kong
  and Shanghai Hotels Limited
• InterContinental
  Hotels Group PLC
• Marriott
  International Inc.
• MGM China
  Holdings Limited
• Miramar
  Hotel & Investment Company Limited
• Sands
  China Limited
• Wyndham
  Hotels & Resorts Inc.

The 6^th HKSMEBSI

Overall VPI Scores

	Total	Values	Process – Management	Process – Practice	Impact
6th HKSMEBSI	78.73	86.20	77.80	83.51	68.70
5th HKSMEBSI	77.69	80.40	79.15	83.68	70.03

 

Stakeholder Analysis

	Community	Consumer	Employee	Environment	Government	Investor	Supplier
6th HKSMEBSI	82.64	91.14	77.81	79.12	52.64	50.22	69.22
5th HKSMEBSI	78.96	86.35	81.29	80.50	48.08	60.46	81.65

The Top 10 HKSMEBSI Company Ranking

1.      Meiriki Japan Company Limited

2.      Richform Holdings Ltd.

3.      Jenston Technology Corporation Limited

4.      Ultra Active Technology Limited

5.      Diving Adventure Limited

6.      City Cut Hair & Beauty Salon

7.      Sunta Chemical Limited

8.      Dunwell Enviro-Tech (Holdings) Ltd.

9.      MYLAMSTUDIO

10.   Intimex Business Solutions Company Limited

Participating HKSMEBSI Companies (in alphabetical order)

• Appetizup
  Co., Ltd.
• Arredamenti
  Company Ltd.
• CITYRAY
  TECHNOLOGY (CHINA) LIMITED
• EcoSage
  Limited
• Ensec
  Solutions Hong Kong Limited
• Fast Base
  Enterprises Ltd.
• Future
  Lighting Collection Limited
• Happy Star
  Travel Service Ltd.
• Kennic
  Ltd.
• KL Home
  Care Limited
• Milton
  Holdings International Limited
• OKIA
  Optical Co., Ltd.
• Projexasia
  Limited
• Sailing
  Boat Catering Group Limited
• Silver
  Printing Company Limited
• Sze Wo
  Chaan Gas Co., Ltd.
• Venture
  Global Limited